Beef and Barley with Mushrooms

There's something about the smell of pancetta crisping in a Dutch oven on a gray afternoon that makes you pause whatever you were doing and just breathe it in. That's when this soup came into my life—not from a cookbook or a carefully planned menu, but from standing in front of an open fridge wondering what could transform a few humble ingredients into something warm enough to chase away the cold. The barley does something magical here, absorbing all that rich, beefy flavor while staying wonderfully chewy, and the mushrooms add this earthy depth that keeps surprising you with each spoonful.

I made this for my sister during her first winter in a new city, when she admitted over the phone that she'd been eating cereal for dinner more nights than she wanted to admit. She came over skeptical—she wasn't really a soup person, she said. But somewhere between the second and third bowl, something shifted. She got quiet, the way people do when food hits differently, and asked if I could write down how to make it. I never did, but I like to think she figured it out anyway.

Ingredients

• Beef chuck roast: Cut into half-inch cubes so they braise gently and become impossibly tender; this cut has just enough marbling to keep the meat from getting tough.
• Pancetta: Renders its fat into the pot, creating a flavor base that bacon can approximate but never quite replace—though bacon works if that's what you have.
• Baby bella mushrooms: They're earthier than button mushrooms and release their moisture beautifully as they cook, enriching the broth with every stir.
• Pearl barley: Rinse it first under cold water; this removes some of the starch so the soup stays clear and the barley doesn't clump.
• Beef broth: Low sodium is essential because you'll be reducing the liquid and concentrating flavors, and you want control over the salt level.
• Tomato paste: A single tablespoon stirred into the aromatics adds complexity and subtle sweetness that balances the earthiness of the mushrooms.
• Bay leaves, thyme, and rosemary: Together they create an aromatic backbone that makes the soup smell like comfort itself.

Instructions

Crisp the pancetta and set the tone:

Heat a tablespoon of olive oil in your heaviest pot—a Dutch oven is ideal—over medium-high heat, then add the diced pancetta. You want it to sizzle immediately, curling at the edges and turning a deep golden brown in about 3 to 4 minutes. The rendered fat is liquid gold for this soup, so don't rush it.

Sear the beef properly:

Pat the beef cubes dry with a paper towel (this helps them brown faster), season them generously, then work in batches so the pot stays hot. You're looking for a deep brown crust on all sides, about 5 to 6 minutes per batch—this is flavor you can't fake with broth alone.

Build the aromatic base:

With the beef removed, add your remaining oil and let the onion, carrots, and celery soften for about 5 minutes, stirring occasionally. Add the minced garlic for just a minute longer—any more and it'll turn bitter.

Coax out the mushroom magic:

The sliced mushrooms go in next, and this step takes patience. Let them cook undisturbed for a few minutes so they release their water and begin to caramelize, about 6 to 8 minutes total, stirring occasionally as they soften and darken.

Deepen the flavor with tomato paste:

Stir in the tomato paste and let it cook for exactly one minute in the hot pot, which toasts it slightly and mellows its acidity before you return the beef and pancetta and add everything else.

Bring it all together and simmer:

Return the beef and pancetta to the pot, add the rinsed barley, bay leaves, herbs, broth, and water, then bring everything to a boil. Once it's boiling, reduce the heat to low, cover, and let it simmer gently for 90 minutes, stirring occasionally to make sure nothing sticks to the bottom.

Finish and taste:

Remove the bay leaves, taste the soup carefully, and adjust the salt and pepper as needed. Some broths are saltier than others, so you're the final judge here.

Save to Pinterest

Save to Pinterest

My neighbor once told me that her grandmother made a version of this soup whenever someone in the family was going through something difficult, as if the act of simmering meat and vegetables for hours was a form of care you could ladle into a bowl. I understood exactly what she meant the first time someone sat at my table and felt genuinely comforted by this.

The Barley Secret

Pearl barley is forgiving in a way some grains aren't. It won't turn to mush if you cook it a few minutes longer, and it soaks up flavor like it was born to do exactly that. The first time I made this soup, I wondered if the barley would dominate the bowl, but instead it becomes part of the background, adding body and texture without ever overshadowing the beef or mushrooms. Some people swap it for brown rice or farro if they want something different, and that works, but the nuttiness of pearl barley is what makes this soup distinctly itself.

When to Make This

This is the kind of soup that justifies turning on the oven on a day when you'd rather not heat up the house, because it's autumn or early spring and the weather can't make up its mind. It's also the soup you make when someone's sick, when the week has been too long, or when you just want your kitchen to smell like you care. The two-hour cooking time feels longer than it is because you can do other things while it simmers, just checking in occasionally to stir and breathe in the steam.

Storing, Reheating, and Variations

This soup actually tastes better after a day in the refrigerator, once the flavors have had time to get to know each other, so make it ahead without guilt. It keeps for about four days in an airtight container, and reheats beautifully over low heat on the stovetop—just add a splash of water if it's thickened too much. If you want to deepen the richness, swap half the beef broth for mushroom broth, or add a cup of dry red wine before simmering; either one transforms it into something you'd serve at a dinner party.

• For a gluten-free version, substitute the pearl barley with brown rice or another gluten-free grain, though you may need to adjust the cooking time slightly.
• If you can't find or don't want to use pancetta, bacon works and contributes a smokier note that some people prefer.
• Fresh parsley scattered on top at the end adds brightness and a subtle freshness that contrasts beautifully with the deep, savory flavors underneath.

Save to Pinterest

Save to Pinterest

This soup has become the thing I make when I want to say 'I'm thinking of you' without using words. There's real comfort in knowing how to make something that feeds both hunger and the quieter needs that a warm bowl can address.

Recipe FAQs

→ Can I make this soup ahead of time?

Yes, this soup actually tastes better the next day as the flavors meld together. Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 4 days. The barley may absorb more liquid, so add extra broth when reheating.

→ What cut of beef works best for this soup?

Beef chuck roast is ideal because it becomes incredibly tender during the long simmering process. The marbling breaks down, adding richness to the broth. You can also use beef stew meat or short ribs for similar results.

→ Can I substitute the pancetta with something else?

Absolutely. Bacon is the closest substitute and will provide similar smoky, savory depth. Use the same amount and follow the same cooking method. For a leaner option, omit it entirely and add an extra tablespoon of olive oil.

→ How do I make this gluten-free?

Replace the pearl barley with a gluten-free grain like brown rice, wild rice, or quinoa. Adjust cooking time accordingly—brown rice needs about 45 minutes, while quinoa only needs 15-20 minutes. Always check your beef broth label for hidden gluten.

→ Why do I need to brown the beef in batches?

Crowding the pot lowers the temperature, causing the beef to steam rather than sear. Browning in batches ensures each piece develops a rich, caramelized crust that adds deep flavor to the final soup.

→ Can I use a slow cooker instead?

Yes. Complete steps 1-5 in a skillet, then transfer everything to a slow cooker. Cook on low for 6-7 hours or high for 3-4 hours until beef and barley are tender. This method is perfect for hands-off cooking.